State of the Union 2018: Commission proposes to put an end to seasonal clock changes
On 12 September 2018, on the occasion of
his State of the Union Address, President Jean-Claude Juncker said: "We all say in soap-box speeches that we want to be big on big things and small on small things. But there is no applause when EU law dictates that Europeans have to change
the clocks twice a year. The Commission is today proposing to change this. Clock-changing must stop. Member States should themselves decide whether their citizens live in summer- or wintertime. It is a question of subsidiarity. I expect the Parliament and
Council will share this view and find solutions that work for our internal market. We are out of time."
Today the European Commission is proposing to end seasonal clock changes in Europe in 2019, giving Member States the freedom
to decide once and for all whether they want to permanently apply summer- or wintertime. The legislative proposal seeks to ensure that any changes are made in a coordinated way between neighbouring countries so as to safeguard the proper functioning of the
internal market and avoid fragmentation, which could arise if some Member States kept seasonal clock changes arrangements while others discontinued them.
Commissioner for Transport, Violeta Bulc said: "We are proposing to put an
end to seasonal clock changes as of next year. This very ambitious timetable will allow citizens to reap the benefits without delay. We are now inviting Member States and businesses to make the necessary preparations to ensure a coordinated approach across
The Commission's proposal:
- puts an end to seasonal clock changes for the entire European Union;
- sets out a clear and short timetable for the changes to take effect;
- encourages consultation at national and
European levels, to ensure a coordinated approach among Member States.
Today's proposal is another example of the Juncker Commission being big on the big things, leaving it to Member States to take decisions where they are best placed to do so.
How and when would these changes become effective?
The European Commission's proposal will now go to the European Parliament and the Council for their agreement.
To allow for a smooth transition, under the Commission's
proposal each Member State would notify by April 2019 whether it intends to apply permanent winter or summertime. The last mandatory change to summertime would take place on Sunday 31 March 2019. After this, the Member States wishing to permanently
switch back to wintertime would still be able to make one last seasonal clock change on Sunday 27 October 2019. Following that date, seasonal clock changes would no longer be possible.
This timeline is conditional on the European Parliament and the
Council adopting the Commission's proposal by March 2019 at the latest.
Why is the Commission proposing this change?
European countries introduced summertime arrangements in the last century to save energy, particularly
in times of war or during the oil crisis of the 1970s. Starting in 1980, the European Union gradually adopted legislation putting an end to the diverging schedules of the national clock changes. In 2018 however, the purpose of clock changes has become much
less relevant, with studies suggesting that energy savings are now marginal and citizens increasingly complaining about negative health impacts.
Clock changes have indeed been increasingly questioned by citizens, by the
European Parliament and by a growing number of Member States. Building upon the request of the European Parliament, and as part of an assessment of the current arrangements, the Commission held a public consultation in summer 2018 which received 4.6
million responses, the highest number ever received in any public consultation organised by the European Commission. 84% of respondents were in favour of ending seasonal clock changes.
In light of these elements, the European Commission has concluded
that there is no point for Brussels to keep regulating seasonal time changes and that Member States should be free to decide whether they want to be in summertime or wintertime and handle the matter at national level, in accordance with the principle of subsidiarity.
Website on the State of the European Union 2018
Subpage on Seasonal Clock Changes
Q&A on the Commission's proposal to put an end to seasonal clock changes
Final report of the public consultation